Stage 2. KneadingThe first stage of mixing has nothing to do with mixing itself -
This is a simple determination of the temperature of the mixing water, which is calculated depending on the set temperature of the dough (see the section "Calculation of the set dough temperature"). Obtaining homogeneous, stable products requires compliance with many conditions, including constant temperature control. It's better to spend a few minutes calculating the temperature of the kneading water and get the dough in the right temperature range than biting your elbows later. After determining the temperature of the water, you can start the actual kneading.
What happens in a kneading machine or in a bowl where the dough is kneaded by hand is actually quite difficult to describe.It all starts at the moment when the flour particles and water come into contact with each other and the mixing process begins. Kneading serves several important purposes. The simplest of these is the even distribution of all ingredients in the dough. It is more difficult to describe the formation of gluten (gluten). At first, protein molecules in flour are randomly distributed and can be oriented in any direction. When kneading, these molecules are drawn into more or less straight fibers, and it is this stretching and ordering of the gluten threads that gives the dough "strength". Kneading the dough with the correct development of gluten allows the dough to stretch well, not to burst and retain trapped air and carbon dioxide generated by three yeast fermentation, which in turn determines the volume and color of the loaf after leaving the oven. Everything, of course, is somewhat more complicated. In fact, there are two types of gluten-forming proteins in flour - glutenin and gliadin, the nature of which is somewhat opposite.
Glutenin contributes to the formation of the structure of the dough and its elasticity, or, in other words, increases its tensile strength. Gliadin, on the other hand, gives the dough elasticity, that is, the ability to stretch. The dough requires both, and the correct kneading is required for the simultaneous formation of elasticity and firmness. The balance of these two properties allows the dough to both resist tearing (be elastic) and stretch without breaking (be stretchable). Balancing these two different viscoelastic properties remains an important challenge throughout the process. But, for example, rye flour contains very little glutenin and more gliadin, and therefore the requirements for its kneading and the properties of rye dough for baking rye bread are completely different from those for wheat dough and bread. The method of kneading rye bread is discussed in detail in Chapter 6.
Let's give an example. Imagine that you need to get baguettes by rolling out small, about 200-gram pieces of dough into dough pieces about 60 cm long and with the same diameter along the entire length. If they are too firm (which can be caused by insufficient pre-proofing after rounding or using too strong flour with too much mixing), the dough will resist you a lot during molding and most likely. will win! By the time you manage to achieve the desired length of the baguette, the surface of the workpiece will become torn and uneven, the product will look like it urgently needs a doctor or lawyer. Now imagine that you need to mold hundreds of such blanks! The other extreme is when the dough after layering is too stretchable (due to insufficient kneading of weak flour or due to too long preliminary proofing). At the same time, the dough itself does not look like itself, like a body without a skeleton, it is something "mollusk-like"! When kneaded, it does not offer any resistance at all, the workpieces are flat and shapeless, and they will remain so when baked.
Talking about gluten protein molecules is useful, of course, but I've never seen a baker holding a microscope while kneading. Hand sensations when kneading dough and changes in visual and tactile perception should never be neglected. After loading all the ingredients for the dough into the kneader and turning it on, the flour begins to hydrate. Regardless of the type of kneading paddle, it is very important that the rotation speed is low at first. At this stage, the outer surface of the starch granules is moistened, the ingredients clump together, and dough begins to form. After mixing the ingredients, usually 2-3 minutes after the start of kneading, turn off the machine and taste the dough by touch (it would be nice to taste the dough - did you forget to add salt). The dough should be sticky, "rough", rather liquid, it does not yet have strength, smoothness or elasticity.Immerse your hand in the dough - it parted freely, almost without resistance. This is how it should be at this stage of kneading, because here homogeneity of the dough (uniform distribution of ingredients) is important for us, and not its "strength".
Usually novice bakers at this stage conclude that the dough is too runny and add flour. However, what seemed like a very thin dough at the first stage of kneading will soon (at the second stage, when gluten is forming) turn into a thick, dense dough. The addition of flour early in the batch has already ruined many batches of dough. You can "feel" the transformation of the dough from a liquid shapeless mass into a dense elastic and developed dough only with your hands during the entire kneading process.
After you have made sure that the consistency of the dough is normal, the kneading phase continues, in which the gluten continues to develop. Usually the mixer is switched to the second speed at which gluten is well formed. Touch the dough with your hand - a well-kneaded dough will resist; it has already gained strength, became elastic, but soft and a little springy. Some bakers separate a small piece of dough and stretch it into as thin a film as possible (sometimes referred to as a "windowpane test"). This is just one way to gauge gluten formation, but caution should be exercised: if this thin film is completely transparent and the gluten is fully formed, the dough will almost certainly be “jumbled”, too dense. Correct gluten formation does not mean its complete formation, and, as we will see below, the duration of kneading at the second speed and, therefore, the degree of gluten formation is determined by many factors. If our only goal is to get the required volume of dough, then we can stop at a higher dosage of yeast and maximum gluten formation in the mixer. At the same time, the maximum volume is one thing, but good taste and aroma is another, and the methods of kneading that provide the maximum dough volume, at the same time, negatively affect the taste and aroma.
With each rotation of the kneading body, the dough is stirred and oxygen penetrates into it. The importance of oxygen penetration is due to the fact that it participates in strengthening the gluten framework, however, excess oxygen can have a negative effect on the dough. Too much oxygen will lead to excessive mixing: the gluten bonds begin to break, the dough becomes shiny and sticky as moisture is released from it, the elasticity decreases and the overall structure weakens. Excessive oxidation occurs even before this extreme point is reached, resulting in a deterioration in taste and aroma, that is, the overall quality of the bread.
So what should a baker consider when kneading dough? One extreme is high speed kneading, which maximizes gluten formation and matures directly in the kneader due to oxygen capture and maximum shear forces. In this case, the dough is as "strong" as possible, and fermentation of the dough is almost impossible. Flavoring components of flour - carotenoids, which also give unbleached flour its creamy color - are oxidized due to excessive mixing. This leads to the impossibility of developing taste and aroma, a very long process. The other extreme is a very slow mixing only at the first, slowest speed. The same is observed, for example, when kneading with hands (or even with feet, as has been done for many centuries). At the same time, a minimum amount of gluten is formed, and the oxidation state remains minimal. Fermentation lasts for hours, as the dough ripens, it is repeatedly kneaded, carotenoids are not oxidized, and the taste and aroma of the bread is excellent.At the same time, the volume of the loaf is relatively small due to the poor physical processing of the dough.
There is also a kind of "golden mean": the dough is kneaded in a bowl until the middle stage of gluten formation. Over time, thanks to the kneading, the physical structure is also formed (sufficient fermentation). In the mixer, carotenoids are not oxidized too much, they participate in the formation of the bread taste and aroma, and the bread turns out to be of good volume. Thanks to this, a balance of accurate kneading is achieved without destroying carotenoids, on the one hand, and on the other, good fermentation to obtain the maximum possible taste and aroma, elasticity and strength of the dough, as well as preserve the quality of the product.
There is no doubt that an elastic ("strong") dough is necessary to obtain good bread. However, there are alternative options for achieving full development of the dough in the kneading machine with the inevitable consequences of excessive oxidation and too rapid maturation of the dough. Long-term fermentation and the use of pre-fermented semi-finished products increase the acidity of the dough during its maturation due to the formation of organic acids. One of the advantages of this increased acidity is the hardening of the dough structure. Another effective way to strengthen it is to knead the dough, which has a quick and noticeable effect. It is very important to understand the relationship between the degree of kneading, elasticity ("strength") and the degree of fermentation of the dough. As with other aspects of baking, it is very difficult to quantify the required parameters here because the boundaries are amorphous and flexible. By carefully observing the progress of the batch and its results (that is, the properties of the resulting dough), the baker can well acquire practical skills and an empirical understanding of cause and effect.
Duration of mixingSince the duration of the batch depends on many factors, consider some of them.
Kneading machine type... In the USA, professional bakers are most popular with spiral kneaders, planetary mixers and machines with an inclined kneading body, and in home baking, desktop mixers, similar in principle to planetary mixers, prevail. Different types of mixers differ not only in the number of revolutions per minute at certain speeds - the type of kneading body also acts on the dough in different ways. Mixers with a spiral kneading body are highly efficient and form the dough relatively quickly without excessive oxidation. At the same time, due to their high efficiency, they are able to create an excessive kneading of the dough in a short time, which is why it is necessary to work with them very carefully and carefully monitor the duration of the kneading. Mixers with an inclined kneading body work a little slower and softer (when I follow their work, it always seems to me that I still see two old bakers standing opposite each other over a bowl of dough and kneading his hands, immersed in the bowl to the elbows) ... As in the spiral mixer, the bowl in which the inclined kneading body is immersed rotates together. him. Under the influence of such processing, despite the gentle mode, more oxygen is absorbed into the dough than in spiral mixers, so one of the problems here is the possibility of excessive oxidation of the dough. In planetary mixers, the kneading body is lowered vertically into the stationary bowl from above. Such mixers are rightfully considered universal (multifunctional), since, unlike spiral mixers and dough mixers with an inclined kneading body, in a planetary mixer, not only a hook, but also a spatula or a whisk can be installed as kneading bodies, so that you can knead the dough for a wide variety of products - from biscuits to cookies. Although they are completely ineffective as bakery mixers, they can still make dough for great bread.When working with a fierce type mixer, it is important to know its rpm at different speeds. It is equally important to calculate the coefficient of friction in this type of equipment (for more details, see "Calculation of the set dough temperature").
The amount of dough in the bowl. Once I thought that the dough forms faster if it fills not half, but three quarters of the bowl (bowl), but I was wrong. Indeed, the larger the dough, the greater its mass, which means that during kneading the dough is fermented faster. However, in fact, the less dough in the bowl, the faster the gluten formation occurs. Take a 70 kg kneader. Let's make two kneading doughs: first about 20 kg, and then about 50 kg. During the first kneading of the dough, a greater proportion of the total mass of the dough is processed in one revolution of the kneading body than when kneading the second. This allows gluten to form faster with less dough.
Hydration. Hydration is the proportion of water in the dough relative to the amount of flour. Which dough forms faster - wetter or drier? A very dry dough (hydration no more than 60%) does not have enough moisture for the required degree of flour hydration, and it takes more time for gluten to form. In very wet doughs (hydration above 72%), gluten also forms slowly, as the high moisture content makes it difficult. Therefore, if a dough with 66% hydration requires 3 minutes of kneading at the second speed, then for the same development of gluten in a dough with more or less hydration, a longer kneading is required.
Types of flour. The structure-forming properties of rye flour are much less pronounced than that of wheat flour - it can be kneaded all day without achieving the same development of gluten as in wheat flour. In fact, the requirements for kneading rye flour dough are completely different (see Chapter 6). When kneading a dough made from whole grain wheat flour, coarser flour particles with their corners "pierce" the gluten frame, which somewhat increases the dough kneading time. Bleached flours have their own characteristics. Bleached flour with a high gluten content requires a longer kneading time than bleached flour with a lower gluten content, since in the former case it takes longer to form gluten. Flour from soft wheat varieties, for example, confectionery, rarely forms gluten in general, and if it does, it quickly disintegrates if it is too kneaded. Despite the fact that there are quite effective ways to improve the baking properties of weak flour (for example, adding more leaven, more kneading, increasing the duration of fermentation), it is always recommended to carefully and carefully select the desired flour.
The presence of other ingredients. When fats are added (in the form of butter or vegetable oil, eggs, etc.), they envelop the gluten filaments and delay its formation. As the fat dosage increases, the required kneading time also increases. That is why the dough for products such as brioches, in which the proportion of butter is 40 to 70% by weight of the flour, should be completely kneaded before adding the butter. Sugar softens the structure of the gluten, and as the dosage increases, the duration of the batch should also increase. Finally, when adding grains or flakes (fried, raw or soaked) to the dough, they will "pierce" the gluten framework, and therefore the kneading time must be increased.