Which mixer to choose for kneading tough bread dough?

[Choosing a planetary mixer]

Choosing a planetary mixer

Hello everybody. I choose a planetary mixer from budget options and I can’t decide how. I would like to hear feedback on models 🔗 and 🔗 (the blender is included, but it's not important to me).

We need a mixer to knead tough bread dough. The characteristics seem to be the same, but which one does the best in terms of quality? I read a lot of reviews, the second seems to be praised, the first is 50/50. I would like to know your opinion.

I had Festus, it's disgusting to remember! sharp negative .. but I watch a lot of positive reviews .. maybe someone like a game of cooking, slow washing of all the parts, then putting them in their places and assembling straight into a thrill? happens .. but not for me ..

[with knives]

The term "tough dough" is very flexible. If it's just a "cool" dumplings, then go to the owners of the ankasrum, I'm afraid even the kittens won't cope with the kenwoods. Less "cool", well, like soft dumplings, the Kenwoods seem to have done it, and all the other mixers are cheaper to do something a little steeper than bread, but this operation is for wear and tear.

Owners of more budgetary ones, such as Bosch, farst and others like him, are better off doing cool things in combines (blenders) with knives... Or in bread makers, although in bread makers, too, "cool" means a certain consistency.

[fffuntic]

fffuntic, "cool" I meant for bread, I need to knead bread dough with sourdough.

[Margarita]

Margarita, Duc for bread, the dough is not at all steep, and even quite the opposite

As I understand it, the author is interested in: which combine would be better to knead and knead bread dough from specific two?
but the title of the theme won't attract the right owners.
1. The word "cool", it immediately directs thoughts away from the essence of the issue.
2. it is better to go to the specialized topic on the choice of combines. There are more people there, the owners of these two types may respond.
3. In the title of the topic, give an indication of the types of combines. Kind of which one ... makes bread dough better.

We need a mixer for kneading hard bread dough.

Only wheat or rye too, and how much dough? Perhaps this is also important.
For example, an ordinary bread maker with one stirrer does an excellent job with wheat dough up to 4 glasses of flour (600 g), more is already problematic, as well as rye with even a smaller amount of flour.

Duc for bread, the dough is not at all steep, and even quite the opposite

yes, maybe I didn't put it right, but for budget planetary mixers, bread is already cool) I had a boman of not expensive ones, he did not cope), but at the same time, my brother, also a cheap planetary camry, plowed for four years exactly on kneading bread. Therefore, the question is, I looked at these two, in terms of bowl volume and power.

Only wheat or rye too, and how much dough?

and wheat and rye. Well, kilograms 2.5 - 3. In these two, a bowl of 6.5 liters, so I think they can handle it?

it's better to go to the profile topic on the choice of combines

yes, I took a walk around the forum, I didn't find it much, but of course most of the kenwoods and kitschens) I understand, they are super, but for me (for the price) it's like flying into space))

why just walk. You formulate the question correctly, maybe they will see and go. I didn’t see anything on the bread offhand. But the owner of the First FA-5259 describes
I choose a harvester, blender, processor # 1840
I choose a harvester, blender, processor # 1853
We have a happy owner of a cartoon, happy, sometimes they sell it cheaper for a promotion
I choose a harvester, blender, processor # 1797

I am the owner of a small Bosch.A small bosh5, a 5 liter bowl (rounding up, in fact - less), kneads the dough wonderfully, but, of course, not 3 kg.
You need to buy a big Bosch for three kg. Big bosh 8 and above will not fail with the test, but it is expensive.



by kitfort here is the owner of another model, 5 liters. But the manufacturer is the manufacturer. If a model is not good for bread, then the likelihood of a repeat in another model is high. Ask around
Kitfort KT-1343. Planetary mixer # 2

here it is simpler, but satisfied. You can ask around, the owner often appears on the site
SOS! Choosing planetary mixer # 9



but actually a cool instruction from the kitfort. For 1343 with a 5L bowl, the same requirements are for 1339 with a larger bowl. And according to the instructions, the same requirement is a maximum of 1500 g of flour, water / flour = 3/5, while if the dough is tight, then no more than 1.5 kg. It is the same on models with different bowls

[Lena]

Lena, Thank you so much

Yes, you in a personal immediately write. I'm afraid how people bought the unit, so the topic becomes already uninteresting and if everything is fine, they may not go for a long time, more recipes are already walking and chatters, or even for a long time outside the site, may go on a spree.

I like it first, although I don't have any of the above masochistic habits. There are no difficulties with him. Stirrers are washed by a dishwasher, a bowl by hands. She has such a size that the pin in the center does not interfere at all, this is not a liter jar.
But! I'm afraid that 3 kg of dough is too much for him. I make about 1 kg (500-600 g of flour) of rye - already after howling it squeaks and fidgets on the gear. White, butter easily kneads. Less than 10 proteins (for angel biscuits) did not beat.
But I got a thousand temtomes for 3, at the first prices. Therefore, it will break - and not a pity.

You need to buy a big Bosch for three kg. Big bosh 8 and above will not fail with the test, but it is expensive.

Something I'm not sure that a big Bosch will knead 3kg of dough. I mixed a maximum of 1 kg of flour, it's for Easter cakes. If more - the dough begins to crawl up the hook, into the hole narrower. True, this is exactly the dough for cake, it is more moist, there is no kolobok.
Does 5 Bosch have a 5L bowl? Not 3.5? 5.5L from a large bosch.

[Svetlana]

Svetlana, and you have a 6.5 liter bowl?

[Anna]

Anna, you're right, in 5-ke 3.9. I added a liter to him. It turns out that there is nothing in total too
And I'm not at all sure that the kitforths will also fulfill the declared. They also write there, 1 kg of dense and 1.5 kg of a patty type, although the instructions are based on 1.5 kg of flour. Somehow the flour does not coincide with the dough, or I don't understand why.

Three kg of dough is a lot.

Thank you all for the feedback) after the next kneading of bread dough with handles) I ordered first 5259, let me knead 1.5 kg in it, but still not with my hands) you can knead in several portions if you have something. This mixer now has a good discount on Ozone, so that's it, I decided)
I would be glad to read the reviews of the owners of such a mixer.

Kitfort KT-1343. Planetary mixer # 5
Kitfort was also answered

[Lena]

Lena, thank you very much for your kindness and help. I chose a first, I will try, I really hope that it will not let you down. Will arrive on Saturday.

Well, both of these firms on the forum were often taken in the form of other equipment, small things, and they are quite satisfied.
Therefore, as I understand it, both options should not fail, the choice is more in what is closer to your liking.
The only thing, after all, it's not Kenwood, so it's not worth loading to the limit, monitor the heating of the head and let it rest in time, and I suppose there should be no problems.

[Margocha]

Margocha, What kind of mixer did you take, or planetary mixer? How does it work, are you satisfied / not?